We Mostly Come Out at Night: 15 Queer Tales of Monsters, Angels & Other Creatures

Published in 2024 by Running Press Kids, this anthology was edited by Rob Costello as a deliberate effort to center queer identity within the framework of supernatural and speculative fiction. The collection grew out of a desire to reclaim traditional monster tropes—often used as metaphors for otherness—to tell nuanced stories about belonging, transformation, and the complexities of queer existence. By bringing together a diverse array of established and emerging voices, the book positions itself as a modern successor to classic dark fantasy anthologies, specifically tailored for a young adult audience seeking representation in genre literature.

The editorial vision behind the volume prioritizes the subversion of common horror and fantasy archetypes, shifting the focus from the 'monstrosity' of the characters to their agency and inner lives. Critics and readers have noted that the collection successfully balances its genre-focused thrills with authentic explorations of emotional growth, drawing praise for its cohesion despite the variety of authors included. The design of the anthology aims to bridge the gap between gothic aesthetic sensibilities and contemporary inclusive storytelling, establishing the volume as a notable entry in the expanding canon of queer-focused young adult fiction.